Navigate
HomeStart here
MusingsResearch & long-form
BuildingProjects & learnings
WorkProfessional practice
RunningTraining & races
AboutValues & identity
Life & PlacesCulture, food, travel, cities
Notes & ArchiveJournals, essays, portfolio
Acquired / Case file

The Home Depot

Strategies

Named moves and the patterns they express

What The Home Depot did, when it crystallized, the evidence behind the claim, and where each move sits in the 12-pattern taxonomy.

10 strategies5 patterns4 concepts

Pattern constellation

Of the 12 strategy patterns in the Acquired taxonomy, The Home Depot most prominently practices 5. Size = how many named strategies express that pattern.

Strategic moves · grouped by era

1979-present

Warehouse prices, one-stop selection

A 60,000-square-foot warehouse with 25,000 items, supplied directly by manufacturers, priced 10 to 25 percent below competitors at a 30 percent gross margin when the industry took 45. Price Club's economics with the opposite SKU philosophy: every item for any job under one roof. The bet underneath was that returns to square footage and inventory rise past a threshold. In 1980 the stores were twice Lowe's size with three times the products and four times the transactions.

  • Ben:The pitch is customers are going to love it because we're going to have the lowest prices. We're only going to make a 30% gross margin instead of what's industry standard in hardware retail at that time, 45%.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. Ken Buys Handy Dan, Bernie & Arthur Fired]
  • Ben:In 1980, Home Depot's were twice as large as Lowe's, and they carried three times as many products. Which, if you know us and our Costco zealotry, that sounds like a lot of danger. These are all downsides, right? But what ended up happening is they had four times as many transactions as those smaller Lowe's stores.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. Home Depot's Unique Operating System]
  • Ben:The big box warehouse format itself was the most visible innovation at the time in '79, but the more enduring advantage was the operating system beneath it. Home Depot built a high-volume model and shared the benefits of scale with customers, generated greater traffic, strengthened supplier relationships, supported a broader assortment, and reinvested the resulting productivity into stores, associates, logistics, technology, and price, creating a self-reinforcing flywheel that became increasingly difficult to replicate as the company scaled.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. Home Depot's Unique Operating System (reading the Worldly Partners study)]

Sell the future to suppliers, then let them finance the inventory

With $2 million of capital, the founders talked manufacturers into the longest possible payment terms on the promise of fifty stores to come, turned goods before the bills came due, and served only customers who paid at the register. About half of the inventory was financed by suppliers in 1979; the hosts say the same is true today.

  • Ben:So this resulted in about half of The Home Depot's inventory at any given time actually being financed by the suppliers, which is still true today, just based on payment terms, because they can sell about half the items before they have to owe those dollars to the manufacturers.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. Pat Farrah & The HomeCo Interlude]
  • Ben:We had to be psychologists, lovers, romancers, and con artists to get our suppliers aboard. Our ability to paint a picture of how that would take place: the lowest prices, the widest selection, and great customer service was what convinced skeptical manufacturers to sell merchandise to us in those early years. We didn't have the buying power of our established competitors.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. Home Depot Goes Public & Expands (reading Built from Scratch)]
  • Ben:Two, they realized they couldn't afford to extend payment terms to their customers. Now, they were already thinking this way, but what it did mean is they had to focus on retail customers, like consumers who would just pay cash or, you know, credit cards when they're buying an item so that The Home Depot could get money right away versus businesses.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. Pat Farrah & The HomeCo Interlude]

Saturate one metro before the next

Four stores in Atlanta so one weekend-newspaper blitz paid for itself, then number one in each city before moving on. The density was the 1979 marketing budget; today it is the delivery radius. California has 250 stores and Washington 48, which is what lets 90 percent of American homes reach a million SKUs within 2 to 24 hours.

  • Ben:And this is actually the playbook that they would run for the next 45 years is open in one city, saturate that city, become number one, and then move to the next city. Don't sprinkle some stores here and there. No, go into a city with force.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. First Stores & Early Model]
  • Ben:But, you know, if you wanna have that value proposition: 90% of homes can get anything they need for a project, a million SKUs with 2 to 24 hours, that requires two things. One, being really close to lots and lots of stores, which was their initial market strategy to go really dense before going to the next city. And two, to have a just ridiculous distribution center footprint to facilitate the e-commerce component.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. E-commerce & Distribution Revolution]

1980s-present

Hire the trades to teach the customer

Former plumbers, electricians and carpenters staffed the floor and were told to stop and show a customer the job. Before YouTube, that made the store the only place a homeowner could learn to build a deck, and the first project led to the next. The legend of the 25-cent washer that became a $100,000 kitchen is the culture's own parable. The corporate office is the store support center; there is no headquarters.

  • David:They actually need to bundle education with the products that they're selling their customers. And rather than going out and hiring separate teachers that are going to run clinics in Home Depot's, they just recruit employees from the trades who are professional tradesmen, contractors to come be their retail staff in the stores.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. Home Depot's Unique Operating System]
  • David:The store associate who has plumbing experience looks at the faucet and says, oh, no, no, you don't need a new faucet. Like, we can fix this. Let's go get a new washer. That's all you need. We'll get a new washer. It's $0.25. Install it. And, you know, you're going to be good to go. They do. The customer is so happy. He goes home. He tells his wife and family. Next thing you know, a couple of weeks later, he's back and he says, you know, we've been thinking about a kitchen remodel. We're going to do it with you guys here at Home Depot. And it's a $100,000 sale.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. Home Depot's Unique Operating System]
  • Ben:They have a store support center because headquarters merely exists to support the stores.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. Home Depot's Unique Operating System]

1981-2000

Equity all the way down to the store floor

Options from assistant store manager up; for hourly associates, a stock purchase plan at a 15 percent discount with a no-loss guarantee, and onboarding that taught the link between a good day on the floor and the share price. Going public at $32 million left the upside to be shared. Thousands of early associates became millionaires, and the break room watching the ticker was the health check.

  • David:The way it worked was if you were a salaried employee, which started at assistant store manager, you got stock options. If you were an hourly employee, you couldn't be granted stock options, but you got this stock purchasing program, which in the early days they set up as you can buy stock at a 15% discount to the current trading price, and we'll give you a no-risk guarantee.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. Home Depot's Unique Operating System]
  • David:There are thousands and thousands of early Home Depot associates who became multimillionaires because of this.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. Home Depot's Unique Operating System]
  • Ben:He said, the best sign of cultural health is walking into the break room and seeing the associates watching the stock price.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. Home Depot's Unique Operating System (relaying Frank Blake)]

1996-present

Two customers, one store: the pro desk

From the mid-1990s the same store serves the contractor and the weekend homeowner on different terms: business credit, a pro desk, volume pricing open to anyone who buys enough, job-site delivery. Pros are about half of sales; a pro who has built the store into a daily workflow is the switching cost the hosts rate highest.

  • David:This era is when they really start serving the pro contractor market as well as the DIY weekend warrior. They offer business credit accounts. They're finally on solid enough financial footing that they can do that. They start carrying more pro-line tools like DeWalt or Milwaukee tools.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. Arthur Blank Takes CEO & Early Cracks]
  • Ben:Today, there's some switching costs with the house brands, but I'd say the switching costs are probably more for pros who have just integrated Home Depot into their workflow.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. 7 Powers: Home Depot's Competitive Advantages]

2000-2007

Centralize buying; the Nardelli years as the counter-example

Nine buying offices folded into one and new systems fixed real problems left by two decades of decentralization. The same program replaced tradespeople with part-time general retail labor, cut associates per store from 200 to 170, required college degrees of store managers, and paid the CEO without reference to the share price. Revenue and profit doubled on store count; comparable sales stayed flat, customer satisfaction fell to last among major retailers, and $20 billion of buybacks and dividends did not move the stock.

  • Ben:He took nine separate buying offices and folded them into one, so they were suddenly getting better prices from their suppliers. He invested in a bunch of new technology systems.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. The Bob Nardelli Era]
  • David:He replaces huge swaths of the associate on the floor retail workforce in Home Depot with part-time general retail labor. So doing away with the whole philosophy that made Home Depot of we have knowledgeable people who are going to make that $0.25 washer sale and fix a customer's kitchen sink and have that lead to something bigger down the line.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. The Bob Nardelli Era]
  • David:Same-store sales comps had already trended flat before Nardelli joins. They actually stay flat for his tenure. So Wall Street keeps bringing this up as a major red flag and comparing Home Depot to Lowe's, which is growing same-store comps as they're taking this new segment of the market, you know, the weekend sprucers here. And it gets even worse. During Nardelli's tenure, he authorizes $20 billion in share buybacks and dividends. That doesn't even move the stock price.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. Nardelli's Public Downfall & Firing]

2007-2014

Sell HD Supply, buy back a third of the company

In the summer of 2007, with the housing bubble bursting, Blake and Langone put the $8.3 billion from the HD Supply sale into Home Depot's own shares: 14 percent of the float in the first year, 30 percent over Blake's tenure, mostly at $30 to $50 a share. The share count came back to roughly where it stood at the IPO, and the stock rose 132 percent from 2008 to 2012.

  • Ben:So what they do with the $8.3 billion, and this is ballsy, they put it all into buybacks. They just bet on themselves. They said, I think the best ROI thing we can do is buy Home Depot stock with this $8 billion.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. Frank Blake's Turnaround]
  • David:Buying back 30% of your company's share base starting in the summer of 2007. While you're in the housing industry, as the housing bubble is popping real time, continuing this buyback program through the financial crisis. This is all Ken Langone right here.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. Frank Blake's Turnaround]
  • Ben:The graph of the total number of outstanding shares is almost this perfect uphill-downhill that's centered right around the year 2001. But the number of outstanding shares today is almost all the way back down to where it was at IPO.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. Frank Blake's Turnaround]

2008-2019

Freeze the store count, grow the store

About 2,300 stores in 2008, roughly 2,400 today. Blake closed 30, wrote off a billion dollars of pipeline, and opened almost nothing for eleven years. Revenue went from $70 billion to $130 billion and net income from $4 billion to $11 billion on the stores already open; sales per store doubled from about $30 million to $65 million.

  • Ben:So remarkably, while they weren't opening new stores, they grew revenue from $70 billion to $130 billion and net income from $4 billion to $11 billion, all by focusing on the return they could get from their existing stores. So sales per store go from around $30 million to about $65 million over that 11 years per store.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. Frank Blake's Turnaround]
  • Ben:They'd always grown ever since founding by growing stores. It was this safety net that we will always show growth because we are always growing stores, which means, A, you don't really optimize the stores you have. And B, if you believe opening stores is intrinsically virtuous, then you just open more stores whether it was a good idea or not.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. Frank Blake's Turnaround]

2009-present

Build the logistics Amazon cannot copy

Rapid deployment centers from 2009, direct fulfillment centers from 2014, flatbed centers for pro orders, 160 market delivery operations for bulky goods, and the stores themselves as pickup and same-day points. Lumber by the ton does not fit a delivery van, and a job stops when the grout runs out, so store pickup is most of the e-commerce. HD Supply and SRS extend the network outside the store walls.

  • David:So the net of all that is building towards what Home Depot's strategy is today: 90% of all homes in America can get anything they need for any project, over a million SKUs delivered to their home or job site or a nearby store within 2 to 24 hours.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. E-commerce & Distribution Revolution]
  • Ben:They have seven import distribution centers to bring things in from outside the country. They have 18 rapid deployment centers, which take goods from manufacturers, cut them up, get the merchandise into stores. There are 17 flatbed distribution centers, which are all about fulfilling those massive orders to pros. They also have 160 market delivery operations centers, which are cross-dock facilities for other large items like patio furniture that they don't want to route through stores. For e-commerce, they have 20 dedicated direct fulfillment centers that are just for that, which they started in 2014.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. E-commerce & Distribution Revolution]
  • David:I think there is still counterpositioning today. It's just very different. It's counterpositioning versus Amazon. With their logistics and fulfillment network. Amazon is building out more specialty fulfillment and logistics, but it's going to be really hard for Amazon to build and match the scale of what Home Depot has in hardware.
    [Acquired The Home Depot, ch. 7 Powers: Home Depot's Competitive Advantages]